kitchen islands for sale
    HomeAbout Us | Contact Us
June 29, 2020

The Winner of the Granite vs Corian Countertops Debate: You Decide! 


granite vs corian countertops The battle of granite vs Corian countertops has been ongoing since the synthetic substance was added to the kitchen remodeling marketplace over four decades ago.  There are many factors that can be compared, as they both have their strengths and their weaknesses.  Use the following points to help you to decide the winner between granite vs Corian countertops in terms of your needs and your own kitchen.

Granite vs Corian countertops: a question of cost

When faced with comparing granite vs Corian  countertops, a good jumping off point is the cost.  After all, if one doesn’t fit within your budget, that rules it out rather quickly.  Keep in mind that the price of installation will need to be factored in to both of these options for kitchen remodeling projects, as neither one of them is practical as a do-it-yourself task for a homeowner who does not already do this as a profession.    Here are the granite vs Corian countertops average prices:

  • Granite – for an average quality granite counter of 28.3 feet (a common length), including a backsplash of the same material, as well as a double sink cut out of 14” by 16”, it will usually cost in around $2,850 when using a conservative cost estimate of $85.00 per square foot.
  • Corian – for an average Corian Atlantis countertop of the same length and with the same features, you will usually need to pay somewhere between $2,400 and $3,340.

Therefore, in terms of cost, the granite vs Corian countertops answer appears to be a tie.  That said, those numbers are based on a lower end granite slab and a higher grade Corian material, which can lean the argument toward the artificial counter.

Granite vs Corian countertops: a matter of visual appeal

When comparing granite vs Corian countertops, both types can appeal to the old adage that beauty is in the eye of the beholder.  However, when you get right down to it, most homeowners and kitchen remodeling designers lean toward the natural luxury and appeal of real granite. In terms of attractiveness, while both do have their strengths, granite is usually the choice option.

Granite vs Corian countertops: an issue of investment value

Like many people, you may be comparing granite vs Corian countertops not only to suit your kitchen d├ęcor and practicality, but also to invest in the value of your home for when the time comes that you wish to sell it.  Between granite vs Corian countertops, granite does tend to stand out to prospective buyers when it is mentioned in a home’s listing.  That said, Corian certainly doesn’t do any harm, either.  Among all of the artificial materials used for counters, Corian is the most widely recognized name brand.

Granite vs Corian countertops: a word about durability and care

Though durability and care are two different issues, in terms of comparing the lasting nature of granite vs Corian countertops, the matter of care plays an exceptionally important role, to the point that the two cannot be separated.  Granite, no matter how good the quality, must be sealed.  If you don’t do it yourself, then it will have to already have been done when the slab was manufactured, at an additional cost.  Most granite countertops will also need to be treated on occasion, as well.  Corian does not require sealing or treatment.  It is also much harder to crack Corian counters than it is to crack granite.  Furthermore, should any dents or scratches occur on the surface of a Corian counter, they can be carefully buffed out, which is not possible with granite.  For durability and care, Corian wins.

Granite vs Corian countertops: the subject of installation

Where installation is concerned, the granite vs Corian countertops battle essentially tied, as both types of  surface need professional installation.  That said, it should be noted that Corian does have the advantage of greater flexibility for installation than granite.

By looking into granite vs Corian countertops, it is plain to see that both materials have their own strengths and weaknesses.  Consider the above points and have a look at some samples of the two types.  Educate yourself and don’t hesitate to go with your gut.

Back to the Kitchen Islands For home page